How do domestic violence restraining orders work in California, and what happens when the allegations are contested in court? A recent legal battle between Halle Berry and her ex-husband, Olivier Martinez, provides a real-world example of the process, from obtaining a temporary order to presenting evidence at a hearing and receiving a final ruling.
On October 29, 2026, a Los Angeles judge dissolved the temporary restraining order Martinez had obtained against Berry. However, Berry’s overnight visits with their son remained restricted. As reported by the Los Angeles Times, the case illustrates why a favorable ruling on a restraining order does not necessarily resolve related child custody issues.
How Does Someone Obtain a Temporary Domestic Violence Restraining Order?
A domestic violence restraining order (DVRO) is a court order intended to protect someone from abuse by a spouse, former spouse, dating partner, or certain family members. According to the California Courts’ official Self-Help Guide, these orders can prohibit contact, require someone to stay away, and establish temporary child custody and visitation restrictions.
A person seeking protection begins by filing court forms describing the alleged abuse. A judge can grant a temporary restraining order (TRO) before hearing from the accused person. The court then schedules a hearing where both sides can present evidence.
In Berry’s case, Martinez obtained a temporary domestic violence restraining order after alleging that Berry physically assaulted their son during a September incident. Berry denied the allegations. The judge initially granted temporary protection and modified Berry’s parenting schedule.
What Happens at a Domestic Violence Restraining Order Hearing?
A temporary restraining order is not necessarily the final decision. The accused person generally has an opportunity to respond and contest the allegations at a hearing.
Both sides may present evidence, including:
-
Written declarations describing alleged incidents.
-
Text messages, photographs, or other documentation.
-
Testimony from the parties and witnesses.
-
Relevant medical, school, or other records.
Berry’s case demonstrates how extensive these proceedings can become. The court heard testimony from Berry, Martinez, their son, and other individuals involved in the child’s life.
According to the California Courts, a judge may grant a longer-term domestic violence restraining order lasting up to five years if the legal requirements are met.
Why Did the Judge Dismiss the Restraining Order?
After hearing the evidence, Judge Shelley Kaufman determined that Martinez had not met the applicable burden of proof for a longer-term protective order.
The temporary restraining order was dissolved, and Martinez’s request for a longer-term order was denied.
This distinction matters. A temporary order can be issued based on an initial application, but the court may reach a different conclusion after both parties present their evidence.
Importantly, dismissal does not necessarily establish that every allegation was false. It means the evidence did not satisfy the legal requirements for the requested order.
Can Custody Restrictions Remain After a Restraining Order Is Dismissed?
Yes. Perhaps the most interesting aspect of Berry’s case is that the judge left her modified parenting schedule in place despite dissolving the restraining order.
Martinez retained primary physical custody under the temporary arrangement, and Berry’s overnight parenting time remained restricted. The court also ordered joint therapy sessions for Berry and her son.
California custody decisions focus on the child’s best interests, including health, safety, and welfare. As explained by the California Courts, judges may consider allegations of abuse and impose appropriate parenting restrictions.
A restraining order hearing and a custody determination involve related but distinct legal questions.
What Can Parents Learn From This Case?
Berry’s experience highlights several practical lessons for California parents involved in contested family court proceedings:
-
Document important events. Preserve relevant communications and records.
-
Prepare for conflicting testimony. Judges may hear very different accounts of the same incident.
-
Follow temporary orders. Court restrictions remain enforceable until changed.
-
Understand the separate issues. A favorable restraining order ruling does not automatically restore previous custody arrangements.
-
Focus on the child’s best interests. Custody decisions involve more than determining which parent prevailed in a particular hearing.
Get Help With California Domestic Violence Restraining Orders and Custody Disputes
Domestic violence restraining orders and custody proceedings can have significant consequences for parents and children. Understanding the evidence, court procedures, and applicable legal standards is essential.
The Law Office of David Knecht assists clients with California family law matters, including domestic violence restraining orders and contested custody disputes. For assistance in Vacaville, Fairfield, and surrounding Solano County communities, call (707) 451-4502.
